Annual review season is stressful. You know you did good work this year, but when you sit down to write your self-evaluation, everything blurs together into “did my job.”
This guide gives you concrete examples you can adapt, a template to structure your response, and a method for writing accomplishments that demonstrate real impact.
Why Self-Evaluations Matter
Your manager doesn’t see everything you do. They’re busy with their own work, meetings, and managing others. Your self-evaluation is your chance to remind them of your contributions and provide the evidence they’ll use when advocating for your promotion or raise.
A strong self-evaluation does three things:
- Documents your accomplishments with specific examples and metrics
- Shows your growth in skills, responsibilities, or impact
- Demonstrates self-awareness about areas for improvement
The STAR Method for Self-Evaluations
The STAR method gives your accomplishments structure. Instead of vague statements, you provide context that makes your work memorable.
S - Situation: What was the context or challenge? T - Task: What were you responsible for? A - Action: What specific steps did you take? R - Result: What was the outcome? Include numbers when possible.
Example Using STAR
Weak version: “Improved the onboarding process.”
STAR version: “When new hire onboarding was taking 2 weeks and causing delays in project staffing (Situation), I was asked to streamline the process (Task). I audited the existing 47-step checklist, eliminated redundant steps, automated account provisioning, and created a self-service resource hub (Action). New hires now reach full productivity in 5 days, and hiring managers report 90% satisfaction with the new process (Result).”
Self-Evaluation Template
Use this structure for each major section of your self-evaluation:
## Key Accomplishments
### [Accomplishment 1 Title]
- Situation: [Context or challenge]
- What I did: [Your specific actions]
- Result: [Outcome with metrics if possible]
### [Accomplishment 2 Title]
- Situation: [Context or challenge]
- What I did: [Your specific actions]
- Result: [Outcome with metrics if possible]
[Continue for 3-5 key accomplishments]
## Goals Review
- [Goal 1]: [Status and what you achieved]
- [Goal 2]: [Status and what you achieved]
## Skills Developed
- [Skill]: [How you developed it and how you've applied it]
## Areas for Growth
- [Area]: [What you're doing to improve]
## Goals for Next Year
- [Goal 1]: [Why this matters and how you'll measure success]Self-Evaluation Examples by Category
Project Delivery
Example 1: Shipping a Major Feature “Led the development of the customer dashboard redesign, our largest UX project of the year. Coordinated a cross-functional team of 6 over 4 months, managed scope when timeline pressure emerged, and delivered on schedule. The new dashboard reduced customer support tickets related to navigation by 45% and improved user task completion rates from 67% to 89%.”
Example 2: Meeting a Tight Deadline “Delivered the Q3 compliance audit ahead of the regulatory deadline despite starting 3 weeks late due to vendor delays. Reorganized the team’s priorities, worked with legal to parallelize reviews, and created a tracking system that kept all 12 stakeholders aligned. We passed the audit with zero findings, avoiding potential fines of up to $500K.”
Problem Solving
Example 3: Resolving a Critical Issue “Identified and resolved a data synchronization bug that was causing incorrect inventory counts for our top 50 retail customers. Diagnosed the root cause within 24 hours, implemented a fix that reconciled historical data, and created monitoring to prevent recurrence. This resolved 73 open support tickets and prevented an estimated $200K in potential customer churn.”
Example 4: Improving a Broken Process “Recognized that our sprint planning process was causing consistent overcommitment, leading to team burnout and missed deadlines. Proposed a capacity-based planning approach, piloted it with my team, and documented the results. After adoption, sprint completion rate improved from 62% to 91%, and team satisfaction scores increased by 15 points.”
Leadership and Collaboration
Example 5: Mentoring Others “Mentored two junior team members through their first year. Created structured 1:1 agendas, paired on challenging tasks, and advocated for stretch assignments. Both received ‘exceeds expectations’ ratings, and one was promoted to mid-level 6 months ahead of the typical timeline.”
Example 6: Cross-Functional Impact “Established a regular sync between Engineering and Customer Success that didn’t exist before. This collaboration surfaced 15 UX pain points we weren’t tracking, 8 of which we addressed this year. Customer satisfaction scores for the features we improved increased from 3.2 to 4.1 out of 5.”
Business Impact
Example 7: Revenue Contribution “Developed the pricing calculator that sales uses for enterprise quotes. Built it in 3 weeks, iterated based on sales feedback, and integrated it with our CRM. The tool is now used for 100% of enterprise deals, and sales reports it reduces quote turnaround from 3 days to 2 hours. Enterprise close rate improved from 18% to 24% in the half since launch.”
Example 8: Cost Savings “Renegotiated our cloud infrastructure contracts and optimized resource allocation across our AWS environment. Annual infrastructure costs reduced by $180K (22% savings) while handling 40% more traffic than last year. Documented the optimization playbook for other teams to follow.”
Learning and Growth
Example 9: Skill Development “Completed certification in product analytics and applied those skills to build our first cohort analysis dashboard. This analysis revealed that users who complete onboarding within 24 hours have 3x higher retention, which directly informed our Q4 product priorities.”
Example 10: Taking on New Responsibilities “Volunteered to lead our team’s incident response rotation after the previous owner left. Created new runbooks, improved alerting to reduce false positives by 60%, and mentored 3 teammates to join the rotation. Mean time to resolution improved from 45 minutes to 18 minutes.”
Addressing Areas for Improvement
Your self-evaluation should include growth areas, but frame them constructively. Show awareness and action, not just weakness.
Weak version: “I need to work on my communication skills.”
Stronger version: “I’ve recognized that my written updates to stakeholders could be clearer and more concise. I’ve started using a structured format for status reports and asked my manager for feedback on my last three updates. The response has been positive, and I’m continuing to refine this skill.”
Weak version: “I should have delegated more.”
Stronger version: “Early in the year, I took on too much individually, which slowed down some deliverables. In Q3, I made a deliberate shift to delegate more tactical work and focus on higher-impact activities. My direct reports appreciated the additional responsibility, and I was able to take on the cross-team initiative that became one of my key accomplishments.”
FAQ
How long should a self-evaluation be? Aim for 1-2 pages. Long enough to provide evidence, short enough to be read carefully. Focus on your top 5-7 accomplishments rather than listing everything.
What if I can’t remember what I did this year? Start with your calendar, emails, and chat history. Look for project kickoffs, deadlines, and congratulatory messages. For next year, consider keeping a running list of accomplishments throughout the year.
Should I only include positive things? Include areas for growth, but frame them as opportunities with a plan for improvement. Your self-evaluation is an advocacy document, not a confession.
What if my goals changed mid-year? Acknowledge the shift and explain why. “My original goal of X was replaced with Y when [business context]. Here’s what I achieved toward the new direction.”
How do I handle accomplishments from team projects? Be specific about your contribution. “As part of the team that launched X, I was responsible for Y” is honest and still claims credit appropriately.
Make Next Year’s Review Easier
The best time to prepare for your annual review is throughout the year, not the week before it’s due.
If you track accomplishments weekly, writing your self-evaluation becomes an editing exercise instead of a memory test. Ten minutes every Friday saves hours of stress in December.
Career Minder helps with this. Use Catch Ups to log your work weekly, and when review time arrives, filter by date range to see everything you accomplished. Generate a review document in minutes instead of days.
Try Career Minder free for 14 daysRelated posts: